Software developers make use of on crowdsourcing during development. Beyond learning from others, developers use online portals such as Stack Overflow as a vehicle for collaboration. However, little is known about developers’ experiences on such platforms, particularly around problems that are encountered online. Such insights could benefit software developers in terms of recommendations for pitfalls to avoid, ways to exploit crowdsourced knowledge, and the provision of insights to improve online code sharing communities. We interviewed 50 practitioners to fill this gap, where outcomes show that software developers’ use of online portals is targeted, and such portals are a lifeline to modern software development. Practitioners are facilitated with code solutions and debugging, often in a very timely fashion. While these experiences are largely positive, practitioners also encounter negative experiences online, some of which could be significantly deleterious to the community. We discuss the implications of these findings, such as creating awareness of the quality and reliability of code snippets, improving code searches, code validation and outdated code detection and attribution of code snippets.