Cliques and their generalizations are frequently used to model “tightly knit” clusters in graphs and identifying such clusters is a popular technique used in graph-based data mining. One such model is the s-club, which is a vertex subset that induces a subgraph of diameter at most s. This model has found use in a variety of fields because low-diameter clusters have practical significance in many applications. As this property is not hereditary on vertex-induced subgraphs, the diameter of a subgraph could increase upon the removal of some vertices and the subgraph could even become disconnected. For example, star graphs have diameter two but can be disconnected by removing the central vertex. The pursuit of a fault-tolerant extension of the s-club model has spawned two variants that we study in this article: robust s-clubs and hereditary s-clubs. We analyze the complexity of the verification and optimization problems associated with these variants. Then, we propose cut-like integer programming formulations for both variants whenever possible and investigate the separation complexity of the cut-like constraints. We demonstrate through our extensive computational experiments that the algorithmic ideas we introduce enable us to solve the problems to optimality on benchmark instances with several thousand vertices. This work lays the foundations for effective mathematical programming approaches for finding fault-tolerant s-clubs in large-scale networks. History: Accepted by David Alderson, Area Editor for Network Optimization: Algorithms & Applications. Funding: The computing for this project was performed at the High Performance Computing Center at Oklahoma State University supported in part through the National Science Foundation [Grant OAC-1531128]. This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under [Grants 1662757 and 1942065]. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/ijoc.2022.1231 .

In critical node problems, the task is to identify a small subset of so-called critical nodes whose deletion maximally degrades a network’s “connectivity” (however that is measured). Problems of this type have been widely studied, for example, for limiting the spread of infectious diseases. However, existing approaches for solving them have typically been limited to networks having fewer than 1,000 nodes. In this paper, we consider a variant of this problem in which the task is to delete b nodes so as to minimize the number of node pairs that remain connected by a path of length at most k. With the techniques developed in this paper, instances with up to 17,000 nodes can be solved exactly. We introduce two integer programming formulations for this problem (thin and path-like) and compare them with an existing recursive formulation. Although the thin formulation generally has an exponential number of constraints, it admits an efficient separation routine. Also helpful is a new, more general preprocessing procedure that, on average, fixes three times as many variables than before. Summary of Contribution: In this paper, we consider a distance-based variant of the critical node problem in which the task is to delete b nodes so as to minimize the number of node pairs that remain connected by a path of length at most k. This problem is motivated by applications in social networks, telecommunications, and transportation networks. In our paper, we aim to solve large-scale instances of this problem. Standard out-of-the-box approaches are unable to solve such instances, requiring new integer programming models, methodological contributions, and other computational insights. For example, we propose an algorithm for finding a maximum independent set of simplicial nodes that runs in time O(nm) that we use in a preprocessing procedure; we also prove that the separation problem associated with one of our integer programming models is NP-hard. We apply our branch-and-cut implementation to real-life networks from a variety of domains and observe speedups over previous approaches.