We present consistent algorithms for multiclass learning with complex performance metrics and constraints, where the objective and constraints are defined by arbitrary functions of the confusion matrix. This setting includes many common performance metrics such as the multiclass G-mean and micro F-measure, and constraints such as those on the classifier's precision and recall and more recent measures of fairness discrepancy. We give a general framework for designing consistent algorithms for such complex design goals by viewing the learning problem as an optimization problem over the set of feasible confusion matrices. We provide multiple instantiations of our framework under different assumptions on the performance metrics and constraints, and in each case show rates of convergence to the optimal (feasible) classifier (and thus asymptotic consistency). Experiments on a variety of multiclass classification tasks and fairness constrained problems show that our algorithms compare favorably to the state-of-the-art baselines.

We present a statistically consistent algorithm for constrained classification problems where the objective (e.g. F-measure, G-mean) and the constraints (e.g. demographic parity, coverage) are defined by general functions of the confusion matrix. The key idea is to reduce the problem into a sequence of plug-in classifier learning problems, which is done by formulating an optimization problem over the intersection of the set of achievable confusion matrices and the set of feasible matrices. For objective and constraints that are convex functions of the confusion matrix, our algorithm requires $O(1/\epsilon^2)$ calls to the plug-in routine, which improves on the $O(1/\epsilon^3)$ rate achieved by Narasimhan (2018). We demonstrate empirically that our algorithm performs at least as well as the state-of-the-art methods for these problems.