In Isabelle/HOL, declarative proofs written in the Isar language are widely appreciated for their readability and robustness. However, some users may prefer writing procedural "apply-style" proofs since they enable rapid exploration of the search space. To get the best of both worlds, we introduce Apply2Isar, a tool for Isabelle/HOL that automatically converts apply-style proofs to declarative Isar. This allows users to write complex, possibly fragile apply-style proofs, and then automatically convert them to more readable and robust declarative Isar proofs. To demonstrate the efficacy of Apply2Isar in practice, we evaluate it on a large benchmark set consisting of apply-style proofs from the Isabelle Archive of Formal Proofs.