Recommendation systems help to predict user demand and improve the quality of services offered. While the performance of a recommendation system depends on the quality and quantity of feedback from users, the two major approaches to feedback sacrifice quality for quantity or vice versa; implicit feedback is more abundant but less reliable, while explicit feedback is more credible but harder to collect. Although a hybrid approach has the potential to combine the strengths of both kinds of feedback, the existing approaches using explicit feedback are not suitable for such a combination. In this study, we design a novel feedback suitable for the hybrid approach and use it improve the performance of a recommendation system. The system enables us to collect more varied and less biased feedback from users. It improves performance without requiring major changes to the inference model. It also provides a unique and rich source of information of the model itself. We demonstrate an application of Colorful Feedback showing how it can improve an existing recommendation model.