Various servers with different characteristics and architectures are hitting the market, and their evaluation and comparison in terms of HPC features is complex and multidimensional. In this paper, we share our experience of evaluating a diverse set of HPC systems, consisting of three mainstream and five emerging architectures. We evaluate the performance and power efficiency using prominent HPC benchmarks, High-Performance Linpack (HPL) and High Performance Conjugate Gradients (HPCG), and expand our analysis using publicly available specialized kernel benchmarks, targeting specific system components. In addition to a large body of quantitative results, we emphasize six usually overlooked aspects of the HPC platforms evaluation, and share our conclusions and lessons learned. Overall, we believe that this paper will improve the evaluation and comparison of HPC platforms, making a first step towards a more reliable and uniform methodology.

High-performance computing (HPC) is recognized as one of the pillars for further progress in science, industry, medicine, and education. Current HPC systems are being developed to overcome emerging architectural challenges in order to reach Exascale level of performance, projected for the year 2020. The much larger embedded and mobile market allows for rapid development of intellectual property (IP) blocks and provides more flexibility in designing an application-specific system-on-chip (SoC), in turn providing the possibility in balancing performance, energy-efficiency, and cost. In the Mont-Blanc project, we advocate for HPC systems being built from such commodity IP blocks, currently used in embedded and mobile SoCs. As a first demonstrator of such an approach, we present the Mont-Blanc prototype; the first HPC system built with commodity SoCs, memories, and network interface cards (NICs) from the embedded and mobile domain, and off-the-shelf HPC networking, storage, cooling, and integration solutions. We present the system's architecture and evaluate both performance and energy efficiency. Further, we compare the system's abilities against a production level supercomputer. At the end, we discuss parallel scalability and estimate the maximum scalability point of this approach across a set of applications.

A lot of effort from academia and industry has been invested in exploring the suitability of low-power embedded technologies for HPC. Although state-of-the-art embedded systems-on-chip (SoCs) inherently contain GPUs that could be used for HPC, their performance and energy capabilities have never been evaluated. Two reasons contribute to the above. Primarily, embedded GPUs until now, have not supported 64-bit floating point arithmetic - a requirement for HPC. Secondly, embedded GPUs did not provide support for parallel programming languages such as OpenCL and CUDA. However, the situation is changing, and the latest GPUs integrated in embedded SoCs do support 64-bit floating point precision and parallel programming models. In this paper, we analyze performance and energy advantages of embedded GPUs for HPC. In particular, we analyze ARM Mali-T604 GPU - the first embedded GPUs with OpenCL Full Profile support. We identify, implement and evaluate software optimization techniques for efficient utilization of the ARM Mali GPU Compute Architecture. Our results show that, HPC benchmarks running on the ARM Mali-T604 GPU integrated into Exynos 5250 SoC, on average, achieve speed-up of 8.7X over a single Cortex-A15 core, while consuming only 32% of the energy. Overall results show that embedded GPUs have performance and energy qualities that make them candidates for future HPC systems.

The performance of High Performance Computing (HPC) systems is already limited by their power consumption. The majority of top HPC systems today are built from commodity server components that were designed for maximizing the compute performance. The Mont-Blanc project aims at using low-power parts from the mobile domain for HPC. In this paper we present our first experiences with the use of mobile processors and accelerators for the HPC domain based on the research that was performed in the project. We show initial evaluation of NVIDIA Tegra 2 and Tegra 3 mobile SoCs and the NVIDIA Quadro 1000M GPU with a set of HPC micro-benchmarks to evaluate their potential for energy-efficient HPC.

In the late 1990s, powerful economic forces led to the adoption of commodity desktop processors in high-performance computing. This transformation has been so effective that the June 2013 TOP500 list is still dominated by x86.