EDBT 2026 Demo / reviewers in the wild / expert
Thomas Serre
dblp:20/358
· DBLP profile ↗
53ranked-venue papers
4as first author
31since 2021 · last 2025
—ORCID · none
Domains — the database's venue-derived domains; a paper can count in several
Artificial intelligence and machine learning · 48 · 3 first-author · 28 since 2021Graphics, computer vision, multimedia, augmented reality and games · 14 · 3 first-author · 6 since 2021Applied, interdisciplinary, general and emerging computing · 2
| Year | Publication | Venue | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Contrastive Knowledge Distillation for Embedding Refinement in Personalized Speech EnhancementabstractPersonalized speech enhancement (PSE) has shown convincing results when it comes to extracting a known target voice among interfering ones. The corresponding systems usually incorporate a representation of the target voice within the enhancement system, which is extracted from an enrollment clip of the target voice with upstream models. Those models are generally heavy as the speaker embedding’s quality directly affects PSE performances. Yet, embeddings generated beforehand cannot account for the variations of the target voice during inference time. In this paper, we propose to perform on-the-fly refinement of the speaker embedding using a tiny speaker encoder. We first introduce a novel contrastive knowledge distillation methodology in order to train a 150k-parameter encoder from complex embeddings. We then use this encoder within the enhancement system during inference and show that the proposed method greatly improves PSE performances while maintaining a low computational load. Thomas Serre, Mathieu Fontaine 0002, Éric Benhaim, Slim Essid |
ICASSP | 1 |
| 2025 | The 3D-PC: a benchmark for visual perspective taking in humans and machinesabstractVisual perspective taking (VPT) is the ability to perceive and reason about the perspectives of others. It is an essential feature of human intelligence, which develops over the first decade of life and requires an ability to process the 3D structure of visual scenes. A growing number of reports have indicated that deep neural networks (DNNs) become capable of analyzing 3D scenes after training on large image datasets. We investigated if this emergent ability for 3D analysis in DNNs is sufficient for VPT with the 3D perception challenge (3D-PC): a novel benchmark for 3D perception in humans and DNNs. The 3D-PC is comprised of three 3D-analysis tasks posed within natural scene images: (i.) a simple test of object depth order, (ii.) a basic VPT task (VPT-basic), and (iii.) a more challenging version of VPT (VPT-perturb) designed to limit the effectiveness of "shortcut" visual strategies. We tested human participants (N=33) and linearly probed or text-prompted over 300 DNNs on the challenge and found that nearly all of the DNNs approached or exceeded human accuracy in analyzing object depth order. Surprisingly, DNN accuracy on this task correlated with their object recognition performance. In contrast, there was an extraordinary gap between DNNs and humans on VPT-basic. Humans were nearly perfect, whereas most DNNs were near chance. Fine-tuning DNNs on VPT-basic brought them close to human performance, but they, unlike humans, dropped back to chance when tested on VPT-perturb. Our challenge demonstrates that the training routines and architectures of today's DNNs are well-suited for learning basic 3D properties of scenes and objects but are ill-suited for reasoning about these properties like humans do. We release our 3D-PC datasets and code to help bridge this gap in 3D perception between humans and machines. Drew Linsley, Peisen Zhou, Alekh Karkada Ashok, Akash Nagaraj, Gaurav Gaonkar, Francis E. Lewis, Zygmunt Pizlo, Thomas Serre |
ICLR | 8 |
| 2025 | Tracking objects that change in appearance with phase synchronyabstractObjects we encounter often change appearance as we interact with them. Changes in illumination (shadows), object pose, or the movement of non-rigid objects can drastically alter available image features. How do biological visual systems track objects as they change? One plausible mechanism involves attentional mechanisms for reasoning about the locations of objects independently of their appearances --- a capability that prominent neuroscience theories have associated with computing through neural synchrony. Here, we describe a novel deep learning circuit that can learn to precisely control attention to features separately from their location in the world through neural synchrony: the complex-valued recurrent neural network (CV-RNN). Next, we compare object tracking in humans, the CV-RNN, and other deep neural networks (DNNs), using FeatureTracker: a large-scale challenge that asks observers to track objects as their locations and appearances change in precisely controlled ways. While humans effortlessly solved FeatureTracker, state-of-the-art DNNs did not. In contrast, our CV-RNN behaved similarly to humans on the challenge, providing a computational proof-of-concept for the role of phase synchronization as a neural substrate for tracking appearance-morphing objects as they move about. Sabine Muzellec, Drew Linsley, Alekh Karkada Ashok, Ennio Mingolla, Girik Malik, Rufin VanRullen, Thomas Serre |
ICLR | 7 |
| 2025 | MTSE: Multi-Target Speaker Extraction for Conversation Scenarios
Thomas Serre, Mathieu Fontaine 0002, Éric Benhaim, Slim Essid |
INTERSPEECH | 1 |
| 2025 | Follow the Energy, Find the Path: Riemannian Metrics from Energy-Based ModelsabstractWhat is the shortest path between two data points lying in a high-dimensional space? While the answer is trivial in Euclidean geometry, it becomes significantly more complex when the data lies on a curved manifold—requiring a Riemannian metric to describe the space's local curvature. Estimating such a metric, however, remains a major challenge in high dimensions.
In this work, we propose a method for deriving Riemannian metrics directly from pretrained Energy-Based Models (EBMs)—a class of generative models that assign low energy to high-density regions.
These metrics define spatially varying distances, enabling the computation of geodesics—shortest paths that follow the data manifold’s intrinsic geometry. We introduce two novel metrics derived from EBMs and show that they produce geodesics that remain closer to the data manifold and exhibit lower curvature distortion, as measured by alignment with ground-truth trajectories.
We evaluate our approach on increasingly complex datasets: synthetic datasets with known data density, rotated character images with interpretable geometry, and high-resolution natural images embedded in a pretrained VAE latent space.
Our results show that EBM-derived metrics consistently outperform established baselines, especially in high-dimensional settings.
Our work is the first to derive Riemannian metrics from EBMs, enabling data-aware geodesics and unlocking scalable, geometry-driven learning for generative modeling and simulation. Louis Béthune, David Vigouroux, Yilun Du, Rufin VanRullen, Thomas Serre, Victor Boutin |
NeurIPS | 5 |
| 2024 | Saliency strikes back: How filtering out high frequencies improves white-box explanationsabstractAttribution methods correspond to a class of explainability methods (XAI) that aim to assess how individual inputs contribute to a model's decision-making process. We have identified a significant limitation in one type of attribution methods, known as ``white-box" methods. Although highly efficient, as we will show, these methods rely on a gradient signal that is often contaminated by high-frequency artifacts. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a new approach called "FORGrad". This simple method effectively filters out these high-frequency artifacts using optimal cut-off frequencies tailored to the unique characteristics of each model architecture. Our findings show that FORGrad *consistently enhances* the performance of already existing white-box methods, enabling them to compete effectively with more accurate yet computationally demanding "black-box" methods. We anticipate that our research will foster broader adoption of simpler and more efficient white-box methods for explainability, offering a better balance between faithfulness and computational efficiency. Sabine Muzellec, Thomas Fel, Victor Boutin, Léo Andéol, Rufin VanRullen, Thomas Serre |
ICML | 6 |
| 2024 | Latent Representation Matters: Human-like Sketches in One-shot Drawing TasksabstractHumans can effortlessly draw new categories from a single exemplar, a feat that has long posed a challenge for generative models. However, this gap has started to close with recent advances in diffusion models. This one-shot drawing task requires powerful inductive biases that have not been systematically investigated. Here, we study how different inductive biases shape the latent space of Latent Diffusion Models (LDMs). Along with standard LDM regularizers (KL and vector quantization), we explore supervised regularizations (including classification and prototype-based representation) and contrastive inductive biases (using SimCLR and redundancy reduction objectives). We demonstrate that LDMs with redundancy reduction and prototype-based regularizations produce near-human-like drawings (regarding both samples' recognizability and originality) -- better mimicking human perception (as evaluated psychophysically). Overall, our results suggest that the gap between humans and machines in one-shot drawings is almost closed. Victor Boutin, Rishav Mukherji, Aditya Agrawal, Sabine Muzellec, Thomas Fel, Thomas Serre, Rufin VanRullen |
NeurIPS | 6 |
| 2024 | RTify: Aligning Deep Neural Networks with Human Behavioral DecisionsabstractCurrent neural network models of primate vision focus on replicating overall levels of behavioral accuracy, often neglecting perceptual decisions' rich, dynamic nature. Here, we introduce a novel computational framework to model the dynamics of human behavioral choices by learning to align the temporal dynamics of a recurrent neural network (RNN) to human reaction times (RTs). We describe an approximation that allows us to constrain the number of time steps an RNN takes to solve a task with human RTs. The approach is extensively evaluated against various psychophysics experiments. We also show that the approximation can be used to optimize an ``ideal-observer'' RNN model to achieve an optimal tradeoff between speed and accuracy without human data. The resulting model is found to account well for human RT data. Finally, we use the approximation to train a deep learning implementation of the popular Wong-Wang decision-making model. The model is integrated with a convolutional neural network (CNN) model of visual processing and evaluated using both artificial and natural image stimuli. Overall, we present a novel framework that helps align current vision models with human behavior, bringing us closer to an integrated model of human vision. Yu-Ang Cheng, Ivan F. Rodriguez Rodriguez, Sixuan Chen, Kohitij Kar, Takeo Watanabe, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 6 |
| 2024 | Understanding Visual Feature Reliance through the Lens of ComplexityabstractRecent studies suggest that deep learning models' inductive bias towards favoring simpler features may be an origin of shortcut learning. Yet, there has been limited focus on understanding the complexities of the myriad features that models learn. In this work, we introduce a new metric for quantifying feature complexity, based on V-information and capturing whether a feature requires complex computational transformations to be extracted. Using this V-information metric, we analyze the complexities of 10,000 features—represented as directions in the penultimate layer—that were extracted from a standard ImageNet-trained vision model. Our study addresses four key questions:
First, we ask what features look like as a function of complexity, and find a spectrum of simple-to-complex features present within the model. Second, we ask when features are learned during training. We find that simpler features dominate early in training, and more complex features emerge gradually. Third, we investigate where within the network simple and complex features "flow," and find that simpler features tend to bypass the visual hierarchy via residual connections. Fourth, we explore the connection between features' complexity and their importance for driving the network's decision. We find that complex features tend to be less important. Surprisingly, important features become accessible at earlier layers during training, like a "sedimentation process," allowing the model to build upon these foundational elements. Thomas Fel, Louis Béthune, Andrew K. Lampinen, Thomas Serre, Katherine L. Hermann |
NeurIPS | 4 |
| 2024 | Beyond the Doors of Perception: Vision Transformers Represent Relations Between ObjectsabstractThough vision transformers (ViTs) have achieved state-of-the-art performance in a variety of settings, they exhibit surprising failures when performing tasks involving visual relations. This begs the question: how do ViTs attempt to perform tasks that require computing visual relations between objects? Prior efforts to interpret ViTs tend to focus on characterizing relevant low-level visual features. In contrast, we adopt methods from mechanistic interpretability to study the higher-level visual algorithms that ViTs use to perform abstract visual reasoning. We present a case study of a fundamental, yet surprisingly difficult, relational reasoning task: judging whether two visual entities are the same or different. We find that pretrained ViTs fine-tuned on this task often exhibit two qualitatively different stages of processing despite having no obvious inductive biases to do so: 1) a perceptual stage wherein local object features are extracted and stored in a disentangled representation, and 2) a relational stage wherein object representations are compared. In the second stage, we find evidence that ViTs can learn to represent somewhat abstract visual relations, a capability that has long been considered out of reach for artificial neural networks. Finally, we demonstrate that failures at either stage can prevent a model from learning a generalizable solution to our fairly simple tasks. By understanding ViTs in terms of discrete processing stages, one can more precisely diagnose and rectify shortcomings of existing and future models. Michael A. Lepori, Alexa R. Tartaglini, Wai Keen Vong, Thomas Serre, Brenden M. Lake, Ellie Pavlick |
NeurIPS | 4 |
| 2023 | Don't Lie to Me! Robust and Efficient Explainability with Verified Perturbation AnalysisabstractA plethora of attribution methods have recently been developed to explain deep neural networks. These methods use different classes of perturbations (e.g, occlusion, blurring, masking, etc) to estimate the importance of individual image pixels to drive a model's decision. Nevertheless, the space of possible perturbations is vast and current attribution methods typically require significant computation time to accurately sample the space in order to achieve high-quality explanations. In this work, we introduce EVA (Explaining using Verified Perturbation Analysis) - the first explainability method which comes with guarantees that an entire set of possible perturbations has been exhaustively searched. We leverage recent progress in verified perturbation analysis methods to directly propagate bounds through a neural network to exhaustively probe a - potentially infinite-size - set of perturbations in a single forward pass. Our approach takes advantage of the beneficial properties of verified perturbation analysis, i.e., time efficiency and guaranteed complete - sampling agnostic - coverage of the perturbation space - to identify image pixels that drive a model's decision. We evaluate EVA systematically and demonstrate state-of-the-art results on multiple benchmarks. Our code isfreely available: github.com/deel-ai/formal-explainability Thomas Fel, Mélanie Ducoffe, David Vigouroux, Rémi Cadène, Mikael Capelle, Claire Nicodeme, Thomas Serre |
CVPR | 7 |
| 2023 | CRAFT: Concept Recursive Activation FacTorization for ExplainabilityabstractAttribution methods, which employ heatmaps to identify the most influential regions of an image that impact model decisions, have gained widespread popularity as a type of explainability method. However, recent research has exposed the limited practical value of these methods, attributed in part to their narrow focus on the most prominent regions of an image - revealing “where” the model looks, but failing to elucidate “what” the model sees in those areas. In this work, we try to fill in this gap with CRAFT - a novel approach to identify both “what” and “where” by generating concept-based explanations. We introduce 3 new ingredients to the automatic concept extraction literature: (i) a recursive strategy to detect and decompose concepts across layers, (ii) a novel method for a more faithful estimation of concept importance using Sobol indices, and (iii) the use of implicit differentiation to unlock Concept Attribution Maps. We conduct both human and computer vision experiments to demonstrate the benefits of the proposed approach. We show that the proposed concept importance estimation technique is more faithful to the model than previous methods. When evaluating the usefulness of the method for human experimenters on a human-centered utility benchmark, we find that our approach significantly improves on two of the three test scenarios. Thomas Fel, Agustin M. Picard, Louis Béthune, Thibaut Boissin, David Vigouroux, Julien Colin, Rémi Cadène, Thomas Serre |
CVPR | 8 |
| 2023 | GAMR: A Guided Attention Model for (visual) Reasoning
Mohit Vaishnav, Thomas Serre |
ICLR | 2 |
| 2023 | Diffusion Models as Artists: Are we Closing the Gap between Humans and Machines?abstractAn important milestone for AI is the development of algorithms that can produce drawings that are indistinguishable from those of humans. Here, we adapt the ”diversity vs. recognizability” scoring framework from Boutin et al (2022) and find that one-shot diffusion models have indeed started to close the gap between humans and machines. However, using a finer-grained measure of the originality of individual samples, we show that strengthening the guidance of diffusion models helps improve the humanness of their drawings, but they still fall short of approximating the originality and recognizability of human drawings. Comparing human category diagnostic features, collected through an online psychophysics experiment, against those derived from diffusion models reveals that humans rely on fewer and more localized features. Overall, our study suggests that diffusion models have significantly helped improve the quality of machine-generated drawings; however, a gap between humans and machines remains – in part explainable by discrepancies in visual strategies. Victor Boutin, Thomas Fel, Lakshya Singhal, Rishav Mukherji, Akash Nagaraj, Julien Colin, Thomas Serre |
ICML | 7 |
| 2023 | Learning Functional TransductionabstractResearch in statistical learning has polarized into two general approaches to perform regression analysis: Transductive methods construct estimates directly based on exemplar data using generic relational principles which might suffer from the curse of dimensionality. Conversely, inductive methods can potentially fit highly complex functions at the cost of compute-intensive solution searches. In this work, we leverage the theory of vector-valued Reproducing Kernel Banach Spaces (RKBS) to propose a hybrid approach: We show that transductive regression systems can be meta-learned with gradient descent to form efficient _in-context_ neural approximators of function defined over both finite and infinite-dimensional spaces (operator regression). Once trained, our _Transducer_ can almost instantaneously capture new functional relationships and produce original image estimates, given a few pairs of input and output examples. We demonstrate the benefit of our meta-learned transductive approach to model physical systems influenced by varying external factors with little data at a fraction of the usual deep learning training costs for partial differential equations and climate modeling applications. Mathieu Chalvidal, Thomas Serre, Rufin VanRullen |
NeurIPS | 2 |
| 2023 | A Holistic Approach to Unifying Automatic Concept Extraction and Concept Importance EstimationabstractIn recent years, concept-based approaches have emerged as some of the most promising explainability methods to help us interpret the decisions of Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs). These methods seek to discover intelligible visual ``concepts'' buried within the complex patterns of ANN activations in two key steps: (1) concept extraction followed by (2) importance estimation. While these two steps are shared across methods, they all differ in their specific implementations. Here, we introduce a unifying theoretical framework that recast the first step -- concept extraction problem -- as a special case of **dictionary learning**, and we formalize the second step -- concept importance estimation -- as a more general form of **attribution method**.
This framework offers several advantages as it allows us: (i) to propose new evaluation metrics for comparing different concept extraction approaches; (ii) to leverage modern attribution methods and evaluation metrics to extend and systematically evaluate state-of-the-art concept-based approaches and importance estimation techniques; (iii) to derive theoretical guarantees regarding the optimality of such methods.
We further leverage our framework to try to tackle a crucial question in explainability: how to *efficiently* identify clusters of data points that are classified based on a similar shared strategy.
To illustrate these findings and to highlight the main strategies of a model, we introduce a visual representation called the strategic cluster graph. Finally, we present Lens, a dedicated website that offers a complete compilation of these visualizations for all classes of the ImageNet dataset. Thomas Fel, Victor Boutin, Louis Béthune, Rémi Cadène, Mazda Moayeri, Léo Andéol, Mathieu Chalvidal, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 8 |
| 2023 | Unlocking Feature Visualization for Deep Network with MAgnitude Constrained OptimizationabstractFeature visualization has gained significant popularity as an explainability method, particularly after the influential work by Olah et al. in 2017. Despite its success, its widespread adoption has been limited due to issues in scaling to deeper neural networks and the reliance on tricks to generate interpretable images. Here, we describe MACO, a simple approach to address these shortcomings. It consists in optimizing solely an image's phase spectrum while keeping its magnitude constant to ensure that the generated explanations lie in the space of natural images. Our approach yields significantly better results -- both qualitatively and quantitatively -- unlocking efficient and interpretable feature visualizations for state-of-the-art neural networks. We also show that our approach exhibits an attribution mechanism allowing to augment feature visualizations with spatial importance. Furthermore, we enable quantitative evaluation of feature visualizations by introducing 3 metrics: transferability, plausibility, and alignment with natural images. We validate our method on various applications and we introduce a website featuring MACO visualizations for all classes of the ImageNet dataset, which will be made available upon acceptance.
Overall, our study unlocks feature visualizations for the largest, state-of-the-art classification networks without resorting to any parametric prior image model, effectively advancing a field that has been stagnating since 2017 (Olah et al, 2017). Thomas Fel, Thibaut Boissin, Victor Boutin, Agustin M. Picard, Paul Novello, Julien Colin, Drew Linsley, Tom Rousseau, Rémi Cadène, Lore Goetschalckx, Laurent Gardes, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 12 |
| 2023 | Computing a human-like reaction time metric from stable recurrent vision modelsabstractThe meteoric rise in the adoption of deep neural networks as computational models of vision has inspired efforts to ``align” these models with humans. One dimension of interest for alignment includes behavioral choices, but moving beyond characterizing choice patterns to capturing temporal aspects of visual decision-making has been challenging. Here, we sketch a general-purpose methodology to construct computational accounts of reaction times from a stimulus-computable, task-optimized model. Specifically, we introduce a novel metric leveraging insights from subjective logic theory summarizing evidence accumulation in recurrent vision models. We demonstrate that our metric aligns with patterns of human reaction times for stimulus manipulations across four disparate visual decision-making tasks spanning perceptual grouping, mental simulation, and scene categorization. This work paves the way for exploring the temporal alignment of model and human visual strategies in the context of various other cognitive tasks toward generating testable hypotheses for neuroscience. Links to the code and data can be found on the project page: https://serre-lab.github.io/rnn_rts_site/. Lore Goetschalckx, Lakshmi Narasimhan Govindarajan, Alekh Karkada Ashok, Aarit Ahuja, David L. Sheinberg, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 6 |
| 2023 | Break It Down: Evidence for Structural Compositionality in Neural NetworksabstractThough modern neural networks have achieved impressive performance in both vision and language tasks, we know little about the functions that they implement. One possibility is that neural networks implicitly break down complex tasks into subroutines, implement modular solutions to these subroutines, and compose them into an overall solution to a task --- a property we term structural compositionality. Another possibility is that they may simply learn to match new inputs to learned templates, eliding task decomposition entirely. Here, we leverage model pruning techniques to investigate this question in both vision and language across a variety of architectures, tasks, and pretraining regimens. Our results demonstrate that models oftentimes implement solutions to subroutines via modular subnetworks, which can be ablated while maintaining the functionality of other subnetworks. This suggests that neural networks may be able to learn compositionality, obviating the need for specialized symbolic mechanisms. Michael A. Lepori, Thomas Serre, Ellie Pavlick |
NeurIPS | 2 |
| 2023 | Performance-optimized deep neural networks are evolving into worse models of inferotemporal visual cortexabstractOne of the most impactful findings in computational neuroscience over the past decade is that the object recognition accuracy of deep neural networks (DNNs) correlates with their ability to predict neural responses to natural images in the inferotemporal (IT) cortex. This discovery supported the long-held theory that object recognition is a core objective of the visual cortex, and suggested that more accurate DNNs would serve as better models of IT neuron responses to images. Since then, deep learning has undergone a revolution of scale: billion parameter-scale DNNs trained on billions of images are rivaling or outperforming humans at visual tasks including object recognition. Have today's DNNs become more accurate at predicting IT neuron responses to images as they have grown more accurate at object recognition?
Surprisingly, across three independent experiments, we find that this is not the case. DNNs have become progressively worse models of IT as their accuracy has increased on ImageNet. To understand why DNNs experience this trade-off and evaluate if they are still an appropriate paradigm for modeling the visual system, we turn to recordings of IT that capture spatially resolved maps of neuronal activity elicited by natural images. These neuronal activity maps reveal that DNNs trained on ImageNet learn to rely on different visual features than those encoded by IT and that this problem worsens as their accuracy increases. We successfully resolved this issue with the neural harmonizer, a plug-and-play training routine for DNNs that aligns their learned representations with humans. Our results suggest that harmonized DNNs break the trade-off between ImageNet accuracy and neural prediction accuracy that assails current DNNs and offer a path to more accurate models of biological vision. Our work indicates that the standard approach for modeling IT with task-optimized DNNs needs revision, and other biological constraints, including human psychophysics data, are needed to accurately reverse-engineer the visual cortex. Drew Linsley, Ivan F. Rodriguez Rodriguez, Thomas Fel, Michael Arcaro, Saloni Sharma, Margaret S. Livingstone, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 7 |
| 2022 | Diversity vs. Recognizability: Human-like generalization in one-shot generative modelsabstractRobust generalization to new concepts has long remained a distinctive feature of human intelligence. However, recent progress in deep generative models has now led to neural architectures capable of synthesizing novel instances of unknown visual concepts from a single training example. Yet, a more precise comparison between these models and humans is not possible because existing performance metrics for generative models (i.e., FID, IS, likelihood) are not appropriate for the one-shot generation scenario. Here, we propose a new framework to evaluate one-shot generative models along two axes: sample recognizability vs. diversity (i.e., intra-class variability). Using this framework, we perform a systematic evaluation of representative one-shot generative models on the Omniglot handwritten dataset. We first show that GAN-like and VAE-like models fall on opposite ends of the diversity-recognizability space. Extensive analyses of the effect of key model parameters further revealed that spatial attention and context integration have a linear contribution to the diversity-recognizability trade-off. In contrast, disentanglement transports the model along a parabolic curve that could be used to maximize recognizability. Using the diversity-recognizability framework, we were able to identify models and parameters that closely approximate human data. Victor Boutin, Lakshya Singhal, Xavier Thomas, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 4 |
| 2022 | Meta-Reinforcement Learning with Self-Modifying NetworksabstractDeep Reinforcement Learning has demonstrated the potential of neural networks tuned with gradient descent for solving complex tasks in well-delimited environments. However, these neural systems are slow learners producing specialized agents with no mechanism to continue learning beyond their training curriculum. On the contrary, biological synaptic plasticity is persistent and manifold, and has been hypothesized to play a key role in executive functions such as working memory and cognitive flexibility, potentially supporting more efficient and generic learning abilities. Inspired by this, we propose to build networks with dynamic weights, able to continually perform self-reflexive modification as a function of their current synaptic state and action-reward feedback, rather than a fixed network configuration. The resulting model, MetODS (for Meta-Optimized Dynamical Synapses) is a broadly applicable meta-reinforcement learning system able to learn efficient and powerful control rules in the agent policy space. A single layer with dynamic synapses can perform one-shot learning, generalize navigation principles to unseen environments and demonstrates a strong ability to learn adaptive motor policies, comparing favorably with previous meta-reinforcement learning approaches. Mathieu Chalvidal, Thomas Serre, Rufin VanRullen |
NeurIPS | 2 |
| 2022 | What I Cannot Predict, I Do Not Understand: A Human-Centered Evaluation Framework for Explainability MethodsabstractA multitude of explainability methods has been described to try to help users better understand how modern AI systems make decisions. However, most performance metrics developed to evaluate these methods have remained largely theoretical -- without much consideration for the human end-user. In particular, it is not yet clear (1) how useful current explainability methods are in real-world scenarios; and (2) whether current performance metrics accurately reflect the usefulness of explanation methods for the end user. To fill this gap, we conducted psychophysics experiments at scale ($n=1,150$) to evaluate the usefulness of representative attribution methods in three real-world scenarios. Our results demonstrate that the degree to which individual attribution methods help human participants better understand an AI system varies widely across these scenarios. This suggests the need to move beyond quantitative improvements of current attribution methods, towards the development of complementary approaches that provide qualitatively different sources of information to human end-users. Julien Colin, Thomas Fel, Rémi Cadène, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 4 |
| 2022 | Harmonizing the object recognition strategies of deep neural networks with humansabstractThe many successes of deep neural networks (DNNs) over the past decade have largely been driven by computational scale rather than insights from biological intelligence. Here, we explore if these trends have also carried concomitant improvements in explaining the visual strategies humans rely on for object recognition. We do this by comparing two related but distinct properties of visual strategies in humans and DNNs: where they believe important visual features are in images and how they use those features to categorize objects. Across 84 different DNNs trained on ImageNet and three independent datasets measuring the where and the how of human visual strategies for object recognition on those images, we find a systematic trade-off between DNN categorization accuracy and alignment with human visual strategies for object recognition. \textit{State-of-the-art DNNs are progressively becoming less aligned with humans as their accuracy improves}. We rectify this growing issue with our neural harmonizer: a general-purpose training routine that both aligns DNN and human visual strategies and improves categorization accuracy. Our work represents the first demonstration that the scaling laws that are guiding the design of DNNs today have also produced worse models of human vision. We release our code and data at https://serre-lab.github.io/Harmonization to help the field build more human-like DNNs. Thomas Fel, Ivan F. Rodriguez Rodriguez, Drew Linsley, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 4 |
| 2022 | A Benchmark for Compositional Visual ReasoningabstractA fundamental component of human vision is our ability to parse complex visual scenes and judge the relations between their constituent objects. AI benchmarks for visual reasoning have driven rapid progress in recent years with state-of-the-art systems now reaching human accuracy on some of these benchmarks. Yet, there remains a major gap between humans and AI systems in terms of the sample efficiency with which they learn new visual reasoning tasks. Humans' remarkable efficiency at learning has been at least partially attributed to their ability to harness compositionality -- allowing them to efficiently take advantage of previously gained knowledge when learning new tasks. Here, we introduce a novel visual reasoning benchmark, Compositional Visual Relations (CVR), to drive progress towards the development of more data-efficient learning algorithms. We take inspiration from fluidic intelligence and non-verbal reasoning tests and describe a novel method for creating compositions of abstract rules and generating image datasets corresponding to these rules at scale. Our proposed benchmark includes measures of sample efficiency, generalization, compositionality, and transfer across task rules. We systematically evaluate modern neural architectures and find that convolutional architectures surpass transformer-based architectures across all performance measures in most data regimes. However, all computational models are much less data efficient than humans, even after learning informative visual representations using self-supervision. Overall, we hope our challenge will spur interest in developing neural architectures that can learn to harness compositionality for more efficient learning. Aimen Zerroug, Mohit Vaishnav, Julien Colin, Sebastian Musslick, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 5 |
| 2022 | How Good is your Explanation? Algorithmic Stability Measures to Assess the Quality of Explanations for Deep Neural NetworksabstractA plethora of methods have been proposed to explain how deep neural networks reach their decisions but comparatively, little effort has been made to ensure that the explanations produced by these methods are objectively relevant. While several desirable properties for trustworthy explanations have been formulated, objective measures have been harder to derive. Here, we propose two new measures to evaluate explanations borrowed from the field of algorithmic stability: mean generalizability MeGe and relative consistency ReCo. We conduct extensive experiments on different network architectures, common explainability methods, and several image datasets to demonstrate the benefits of the proposed measures. In comparison to ours, popular fidelity measures are not sufficient to guarantee trustworthy explanations. Finally, we found that 1-Lipschitz networks produce explanations with higher MeGe and ReCo than common neural networks while reaching similar accuracy. This suggests that 1-Lipschitz networks are a relevant direction towards predictors that are more explainable and trustworthy. Thomas Fel, David Vigouroux, Rémi Cadène, Thomas Serre |
WACV | 4 |
| 2022 | How and What to Learn: Taxonomizing Self-Supervised Learning for 3D Action RecognitionabstractThere are two competing standards for self-supervised learning in action recognition from 3D skeletons. Su et al., 2020 [31] used an auto-encoder architecture and an image reconstruction objective function to achieve state-of-the-art performance on the NTU60 C-View benchmark. Rao et al., 2020 [23] used Contrastive learning in the latent space to achieve state-of-the-art performance on the NTU60 C-Sub benchmark. Here, we reconcile these disparate approaches by developing a taxonomy of self-supervised learning for action recognition. We observe that leading approaches generally use one of two types of objective functions: those that seek to reconstruct the input from a latent representation ("Attractive" learning) versus those that also try to maximize the representations distinctiveness ("Contrastive" learning). Independently, leading approaches also differ in how they implement these objective functions: there are those that optimize representations in the decoder output space and those which optimize representations in the network’s latent space (encoder output). We find that combining these approaches leads to larger gains in performance and tolerance to transformation than is achievable by any individual method, leading to state-of-the-art performance on three standard action recognition datasets. We include links to our code and data. Amor Ben Tanfous, Aimen Zerroug, Drew Linsley, Thomas Serre |
WACV | 4 |
| 2022 | Understanding the Computational Demands Underlying Visual ReasoningabstractVisual understanding requires comprehending complex visual relations between objects within a scene. Here, we seek to characterize the computational demands for abstract visual reasoning. We do this by systematically assessing the ability of modern deep convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to learn to solve the synthetic visual reasoning test (SVRT) challenge, a collection of 23 visual reasoning problems. Our analysis reveals a novel taxonomy of visual reasoning tasks, which can be primarily explained by both the type of relations (same-different versus spatial-relation judgments) and the number of relations used to compose the underlying rules. Prior cognitive neuroscience work suggests that attention plays a key role in humans' visual reasoning ability. To test this hypothesis, we extended the CNNs with spatial and feature-based attention mechanisms. In a second series of experiments, we evaluated the ability of these attention networks to learn to solve the SVRT challenge and found the resulting architectures to be much more efficient at solving the hardest of these visual reasoning tasks. Most important, the corresponding improvements on individual tasks partially explained our novel taxonomy. Overall, this work provides a granular computational account of visual reasoning and yields testable neuroscience predictions regarding the differential need for feature-based versus spatial attention depending on the type of visual reasoning problem. Mohit Vaishnav, Rémi Cadène, Andrea Alamia, Drew Linsley, Rufin VanRullen, Thomas Serre |
Neural Comput. | 6 |
| 2021 | Go with the flow: Adaptive control for Neural ODEs
Mathieu Chalvidal, Matthew Ricci, Rufin VanRullen, Thomas Serre |
ICLR | 4 |
| 2021 | Look at the Variance! Efficient Black-box Explanations with Sobol-based Sensitivity AnalysisabstractWe describe a novel attribution method which is grounded in Sensitivity Analysis and uses Sobol indices. Beyond modeling the individual contributions of image regions, Sobol indices provide an efficient way to capture higher-order interactions between image regions and their contributions to a neural network's prediction through the lens of variance.We describe an approach that makes the computation of these indices efficient for high-dimensional problems by using perturbation masks coupled with efficient estimators to handle the high dimensionality of images.Importantly, we show that the proposed method leads to favorable scores on standard benchmarks for vision (and language models) while drastically reducing the computing time compared to other black-box methods -- even surpassing the accuracy of state-of-the-art white-box methods which require access to internal representations. Our code is freely available:github.com/fel-thomas/Sobol-Attribution-Method. Thomas Fel, Rémi Cadène, Mathieu Chalvidal, Matthieu Cord, David Vigouroux, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 6 |
| 2021 | Tracking Without Re-recognition in Humans and MachinesabstractImagine trying to track one particular fruitfly in a swarm of hundreds. Higher biological visual systems have evolved to track moving objects by relying on both their appearance and their motion trajectories. We investigate if state-of-the-art spatiotemporal deep neural networks are capable of the same. For this, we introduce PathTracker, a synthetic visual challenge that asks human observers and machines to track a target object in the midst of identical-looking "distractor" objects. While humans effortlessly learn PathTracker and generalize to systematic variations in task design, deep networks struggle. To address this limitation, we identify and model circuit mechanisms in biological brains that are implicated in tracking objects based on motion cues. When instantiated as a recurrent network, our circuit model learns to solve PathTracker with a robust visual strategy that rivals human performance and explains a significant proportion of their decision-making on the challenge. We also show that the success of this circuit model extends to object tracking in natural videos. Adding it to a transformer-based architecture for object tracking builds tolerance to visual nuisances that affect object appearance, establishing the new state of the art on the large-scale TrackingNet challenge. Our work highlights the importance of understanding human vision to improve computer vision. Drew Linsley, Girik Malik, Junkyung Kim, Lakshmi Narasimhan Govindarajan, Ennio Mingolla, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 6 |
| 2020 | Disentangling neural mechanisms for perceptual grouping
Junkyung Kim, Drew Linsley, Kalpit Thakkar, Thomas Serre |
ICLR | 4 |
| 2020 | Recurrent neural circuits for contour detection
Drew Linsley, Junkyung Kim, Alekh Karkada Ashok, Thomas Serre |
ICLR | 4 |
| 2020 | Stable and expressive recurrent vision modelsabstractPrimate vision depends on recurrent processing for reliable perception. A growing body of literature also suggests that recurrent connections improve the learning efficiency and generalization of vision models on classic computer vision challenges. Why then, are current large-scale challenges dominated by feedforward networks? We posit that the effectiveness of recurrent vision models is bottlenecked by the standard algorithm used for training them, "back-propagation through time" (BPTT), which has O(N) memory-complexity for training an N step model. Thus, recurrent vision model design is bounded by memory constraints, forcing a choice between rivaling the enormous capacity of leading feedforward models or trying to compensate for this deficit through granular and complex dynamics. Here, we develop a new learning algorithm, "contractor recurrent back-propagation" (C-RBP), which alleviates these issues by achieving constant O(1) memory-complexity with steps of recurrent processing. We demonstrate that recurrent vision models trained with C-RBP can detect long-range spatial dependencies in a synthetic contour tracing task that BPTT-trained models cannot. We further show that recurrent vision models trained with C-RBP to solve the large-scale Panoptic Segmentation MS-COCO challenge outperform the leading feedforward approach, with fewer free parameters. C-RBP is a general-purpose learning algorithm for any application that can benefit from expansive recurrent dynamics. Code and data are available at https://github.com/c-rbp. Drew Linsley, Alekh Karkada Ashok, Lakshmi Narasimhan Govindarajan, Rex G. Liu, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 5 |
| 2019 | Learning what and where to attend
Drew Linsley, Dan Shiebler, Sven Eberhardt, Thomas Serre |
ICLR (Poster) | 4 |
| 2018 | Same-different problems strain convolutional neural networks
Matthew Ricci, Junkyung Kim, Thomas Serre |
CogSci | 3 |
| 2018 | Learning long-range spatial dependencies with horizontal gated recurrent unitsabstractProgress in deep learning has spawned great successes in many engineering applications. As a prime example, convolutional neural networks, a type of feedforward neural networks, are now approaching -- and sometimes even surpassing -- human accuracy on a variety of visual recognition tasks. Here, however, we show that these neural networks and their recent extensions struggle in recognition tasks where co-dependent visual features must be detected over long spatial ranges. We introduce a visual challenge, Pathfinder, and describe a novel recurrent neural network architecture called the horizontal gated recurrent unit (hGRU) to learn intrinsic horizontal connections -- both within and across feature columns. We demonstrate that a single hGRU layer matches or outperforms all tested feedforward hierarchical baselines including state-of-the-art architectures with orders of magnitude more parameters. Drew Linsley, Junkyung Kim, Vijay Veerabadran, Charles Windolf, Thomas Serre |
NeurIPS | 5 |
| 2016 | How Deep is the Feature Analysis underlying Rapid Visual Categorization?abstractRapid categorization paradigms have a long history in experimental psychology: Characterized by short presentation times and speeded behavioral responses, these tasks highlight the efficiency with which our visual system processes natural object categories. Previous studies have shown that feed-forward hierarchical models of the visual cortex provide a good fit to human visual decisions. At the same time, recent work in computer vision has demonstrated significant gains in object recognition accuracy with increasingly deep hierarchical architectures. But it is unclear how well these models account for human visual decisions and what they may reveal about the underlying brain processes. We have conducted a large-scale psychophysics study to assess the correlation between computational models and human behavioral responses on a rapid animal vs. non-animal categorization task. We considered visual representations of varying complexity by analyzing the output of different stages of processing in three state-of-the-art deep networks. We found that recognition accuracy increases with higher stages of visual processing (higher level stages indeed outperforming human participants on the same task) but that human decisions agree best with predictions from intermediate stages. Overall, these results suggest that human participants may rely on visual features of intermediate complexity and that the complexity of visual representations afforded by modern deep network models may exceed the complexity of those used by human participants during rapid categorization. Sven Eberhardt, Jonah Cader, Thomas Serre |
NIPS | 3 |
| 2016 | An end-to-end generative framework for video segmentation and recognitionabstractWe describe an end-to-end generative approach for the segmentation and recognition of human activities. In this approach, a visual representation based on reduced Fisher Vectors is combined with a structured temporal model for recognition. We show that the statistical properties of Fisher Vectors make them an especially suitable front-end for generative models such as Gaussian mixtures. The system is evaluated for both the recognition of complex activities as well as their parsing into action units. Using a variety of video datasets ranging from human cooking activities to animal behaviors, our experiments demonstrate that the resulting architecture outperforms state-of-the-art approaches for larger datasets, i.e. when sufficient amount of data is available for training structured generative models. Hilde Kuehne, Juergen Gall, Thomas Serre |
WACV | 3 |
| 2015 | Explaining the Timing of Natural Scene Understanding with a Computational Model of Perceptual CategorizationabstractObservers can rapidly perform a variety of visual tasks such as categorizing a scene as open, as outdoor, or as a beach. Although we know that different tasks are typically associated with systematic differences in behavioral responses, to date, little is known about the underlying mechanisms. Here, we implemented a single integrated paradigm that links perceptual processes with categorization processes. Using a large image database of natural scenes, we trained machine-learning classifiers to derive quantitative measures of task-specific perceptual discriminability based on the distance between individual images and different categorization boundaries. We showed that the resulting discriminability measure accurately predicts variations in behavioral responses across categorization tasks and stimulus sets. We further used the model to design an experiment, which challenged previous interpretations of the so-called "superordinate advantage." Overall, our study suggests that observed differences in behavioral responses across rapid categorization tasks reflect natural variations in perceptual discriminability. Imri Sofer, Sébastien M. Crouzet, Thomas Serre |
PLoS Comput. Biol. | 3 |
| 2014 | The Language of Actions: Recovering the Syntax and Semantics of Goal-Directed Human ActivitiesabstractThis paper describes a framework for modeling human activities as temporally structured processes. Our approach is motivated by the inherently hierarchical nature of human activities and the close correspondence between human actions and speech: We model action units using Hidden Markov Models, much like words in speech. These action units then form the building blocks to model complex human activities as sentences using an action grammar. To evaluate our approach, we collected a large dataset of daily cooking activities: The dataset includes a total of 52 participants, each performing a total of 10 cooking activities in multiple real-life kitchens, resulting in over 77 hours of video footage. We evaluate the HTK toolkit, a state-of-the-art speech recognition engine, in combination with multiple video feature descriptors, for both the recognition of cooking activities (e.g., making pancakes) as well as the semantic parsing of videos into action units (e.g., cracking eggs). Our results demonstrate the benefits of structured temporal generative approaches over existing discriminative approaches in coping with the complexity of human daily life activities. Hilde Kuehne, Ali Bilgin Arslan, Thomas Serre |
CVPR | 3 |
| 2013 | Neural representation of action sequences: how far can a simple snippet-matching model take us?abstractThe macaque Superior Temporal Sulcus (STS) is a brain area that receives and integrates inputs from both the ventral and dorsal visual processing streams (thought to specialize in form and motion processing respectively). For the processing of articulated actions, prior work has shown that even a small population of STS neurons contains sufficient information for the decoding of actor invariant to action, action invariant to actor, as well as the specific conjunction of actor and action. This paper addresses two questions. First, what are the invariance properties of individual neural representations (rather than the population representation) in STS? Second, what are the neural encoding mechanisms that can produce such individual neural representations from streams of pixel images? We find that a baseline model, one that simply computes a linear weighted sum of ventral and dorsal responses to short action “snippets”, produces surprisingly good fits to the neural data. Interestingly, even using inputs from a single stream, both actor-invariance and action-invariance can be produced simply by having different linear weights. Cheston Tan, Jedediah M. Singer, Thomas Serre, David L. Sheinberg, Tomaso A. Poggio |
NIPS | 3 |
| 2012 | A New Biologically Inspired Color Image Descriptor
Jun Zhang 0017, Youssef Barhomi, Thomas Serre |
ECCV (5) | 3 |
| 2011 | HMDB: A large video database for human motion recognitionabstractWith nearly one billion online videos viewed everyday, an emerging new frontier in computer vision research is recognition and search in video. While much effort has been devoted to the collection and annotation of large scalable static image datasets containing thousands of image categories, human action datasets lag far behind. Current action recognition databases contain on the order of ten different action categories collected under fairly controlled conditions. State-of-the-art performance on these datasets is now near ceiling and thus there is a need for the design and creation of new benchmarks. To address this issue we collected the largest action video database to-date with 51 action categories, which in total contain around 7,000 manually annotated clips extracted from a variety of sources ranging from digitized movies to YouTube. We use this database to evaluate the performance of two representative computer vision systems for action recognition and explore the robustness of these methods under various conditions such as camera motion, viewpoint, video quality and occlusion. Hilde Kuehne, Hueihan Jhuang, Estíbaliz Garrote, Tomaso A. Poggio, Thomas Serre |
ICCV | 5 |
| 2007 | A Biologically Inspired System for Action RecognitionabstractWe present a biologically-motivated system for the recognition of actions from video sequences. The approach builds on recent work on object recognition based on hierarchical feedforward architectures [25, 16, 20] and extends a neurobiological model of motion processing in the visual cortex [10]. The system consists of a hierarchy of spatio-temporal feature detectors of increasing complexity: an input sequence is first analyzed by an array of motion- direction sensitive units which, through a hierarchy of processing stages, lead to position-invariant spatio-temporal feature detectors. We experiment with different types of motion-direction sensitive units as well as different system architectures. As in [16], we find that sparse features in intermediate stages outperform dense ones and that using a simple feature selection approach leads to an efficient system that performs better with far fewer features. We test the approach on different publicly available action datasets, in all cases achieving the highest results reported to date. Hueihan Jhuang, Thomas Serre, Lior Wolf, Tomaso A. Poggio |
ICCV | 2 |
| 2007 | A Component-based Framework for Face Detection and Identification
Bernd Heisele, Thomas Serre, Tomaso A. Poggio |
Int. J. Comput. Vis. | 2 |
| 2007 | Robust Object Recognition with Cortex-Like MechanismsabstractWe introduce a new general framework for the recognition of complex visual scenes, which is motivated by biology: We describe a hierarchical system that closely follows the organization of visual cortex and builds an increasingly complex and invariant feature representation by alternating between a template matching and a maximum pooling operation. We demonstrate the strength of the approach on a range of recognition tasks: From invariant single object recognition in clutter to multiclass categorization problems and complex scene understanding tasks that rely on the recognition of both shape-based as well as texture-based objects. Given the biological constraints that the system had to satisfy, the approach performs surprisingly well: It has the capability of learning from only a few training examples and competes with state-of-the-art systems. We also discuss the existence of a universal, redundant dictionary of features that could handle the recognition of most object categories. In addition to its relevance for computer vision, the success of this approach suggests a plausibility proof for a class of feedforward models of object recognition in cortex. Thomas Serre, Lior Wolf, Stanley M. Bileschi, Maximilian Riesenhuber, Tomaso A. Poggio |
IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell. | 1 |
| 2005 | Object Recognition with Features Inspired by Visual CortexabstractWe introduce a novel set of features for robust object recognition. Each element of this set is a complex feature obtained by combining position- and scale-tolerant edge-detectors over neighboring positions and multiple orientations. Our system's architecture is motivated by a quantitative model of visual cortex. We show that our approach exhibits excellent recognition performance and outperforms several state-of-the-art systems on a variety of image datasets including many different object categories. We also demonstrate that our system is able to learn from very few examples. The performance of the approach constitutes a suggestive plausibility proof for a class of feedforward models of object recognition in cortex. Thomas Serre, Lior Wolf, Tomaso A. Poggio |
CVPR (2) | 1 |
| 2005 | Learning Features of Intermediate Complexity for the Recognition of Biological Motion
Rodrigo Sigala, Thomas Serre, Tomaso A. Poggio, Martin A. Giese |
ICANN (1) | 2 |
| 2003 | Hierarchical classification and feature reduction for fast face detection with support vector machines
Bernd Heisele, Thomas Serre, Sam Prentice, Tomaso A. Poggio |
Pattern Recognit. | 2 |
| 2001 | Feature Reduction and Hierarchy of Classifiers for Fast Object Detection in Video ImagesabstractWe present a two-step method to speed-up object detection systems in computer vision that use Support Vector Machines (SVMs) as classifiers. In a first step we perform feature reduction by choosing relevant image features according to a measure derived from statistical learning theory. In a second step we build a hierarchy of classifiers. On the bottom level, a simple and fast classifier analyzes the whole image and rejects large parts of the background On the top level, a slower but more accurate classifier performs the final detection. Experiments with a face detection system show that combining feature reduction with hierarchical classification leads to a speed-up by a factor of 170 with similar classification performance. Bernd Heisele, Thomas Serre, Sayan Mukherjee 0001, Tomaso A. Poggio |
CVPR (2) | 2 |
| 2001 | Component-based Face DetectionabstractWe present a component-based, trainable system for detecting frontal and near-frontal views of faces in still gray images. The system consists of a two-level hierarchy of Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifiers. On the first level, component classifiers independently detect components Of a face. On the second level, a single classifier checks if the geometrical configuration of the detected components in the image matches a geometrical model of a face. We propose a method for automatically learning components by using 3-D head models, This approach has the advantage that no manual interaction is required for choosing and extracting components. Experiments show that the component-based system is significantly more robust against rotations in depth than a comparable system trained on whole face patterns. Bernd Heisele, Thomas Serre, Massimiliano Pontil, Tomaso A. Poggio |
CVPR (1) | 2 |
| 2001 | Categorization by Learning and Combining Object PartsabstractWe describe an algorithm for automatically learning discriminative com- ponents of objects with SVM classifiers. It is based on growing image parts by minimizing theoretical bounds on the error probability of an SVM. Component-based face classifiers are then combined in a second stage to yield a hierarchical SVM classifier. Experimental results in face classification show considerable robustness against rotations in depth and suggest performance at significantly better level than other face detection systems. Novel aspects of our approach are: a) an algorithm to learn component-based classification experts and their combination, b) the use of 3-D morphable models for training, and c) a maximum operation on the output of each component classifier which may be relevant for bio- logical models of visual recognition. Bernd Heisele, Thomas Serre, Massimiliano Pontil, Thomas Vetter, Tomaso A. Poggio |
NIPS | 2 |