Rendering produces 2D images from 3D scene representations, yet how continuous variations in camera pose and scenes influence these images—and, consequently, downstream visual models—remains underexplored. We introduce **abstract rendering**, a framework that computes provable bounds on all images rendered under continuously varying camera poses and scenes. The resulting abstract image, expressed as a set of constraints over the image matrix, enables rigorous uncertainty propagation through downstream neural networks and thereby supports certification of model behavior under realistic 3D semantic perturbations, far beyond traditional pixel-level noise models. Our approach propagates camera pose uncertainty through each rendering step using efficient piecewise linear bounds, including custom abstractions for three rendering-specific operations—matrix inversion, sorting-based aggregation, and cumulative product summation—not supported by standard tools. Our implementation, ABSTRACTRENDER, targets two state-of-the-art photorealistic scene representations—3D Gaussian Splats and Neural Radiance Fields (NeRF)—and scales to complex scenes with up to 1M Gaussians. Our computed abstract images achieve up to 3% over-approximation error compared to sampling results (baseline). Through experiments on classification (ResNet), object detection (YOLO), and pose estimation (GATENet) tasks, we demonstrate that abstract rendering enables formal certification of downstream models under realistic 3D variations—an essential step toward safety-critical vision systems.

Learning-based neural network (NN) control policies have shown impressive empirical performance. However, obtaining stability guarantees and estimates of the region of attraction of these learned neural controllers is challenging due to the lack of stable and scalable training and verification algorithms. Although previous works in this area have achieved great success, much conservatism remains in their frameworks. In this work, we propose a novel two-stage training framework to jointly synthesize a controller and a Lyapunov function for continuous-time systems. By leveraging a Zubov‑inspired region of attraction characterization to directly estimate stability boundaries, we propose a novel training-data sampling strategy and a domain-updating mechanism that significantly reduces the conservatism in training. Moreover, unlike existing works on continuous-time systems that rely on an SMT solver to formally verify the Lyapunov condition, we extend state-of-the-art neural network verifier $\alpha,\beta$-CROWN with the capability of performing automatic bound propagation through the Jacobian of dynamical systems and a novel verification scheme that avoids expensive bisection. To demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, we conduct numerical experiments by synthesizing and verifying controllers on several challenging nonlinear systems across multiple dimensions. We show that our training can yield region of attractions with volume $5 - 1.5\cdot 10^{5}$ times larger compared to the baselines, and our verification on continuous systems can be up to $40-10{,}000$ times faster compared to the traditional SMT solver dReal. Our code is available at https://github.com/Verified-Intelligence/Two-Stage_Neural_Controller_Training.