Abstract We present Kofola , an efficient tool for complementation and inclusion checking of Büchi automata, two central tasks in automata-theoretic verification with applications in model checking, monitoring, and theorem proving. Kofola implements a state-of-the-art modular complementation framework that decomposes the input automaton into strongly connected components and applies to each component a complementation algorithm tailored to its structural properties. Building on this modular construction, Kofola also provides modular inclusion checking with new heuristics. A key ingredient is a new on-the-fly emptiness-checking algorithm for the simple generalized Rabin pair condition produced by our complementation, allowing the search to terminate as soon as the explored state space suffices. Empirical evaluation shows that Kofola is highly competitive with state-of-the-art complementation and inclusion-checking tools: it is the most robust tool in our evaluation and often outperforms competitors by several orders of magnitude on benchmarks from practical applications.

Abstract Hoare-style verification provides a principled foundation for reasoning about the correctness of quantum programs, but existing approaches do not allow fully automatic verification. While automata-based verification scales well when specifications are given directly as automata, prior frameworks incur exponential blow-up when translating high-level set-based assertions into automata, which severely limits practicality. We introduce an extended set-based specification language and a specification-to-automata translation algorithm whose complexity is linear in the number of qubits, enabled by controlled automaton construction and qubit reordering. The resulting compact automata enable fully automatic Hoare-style verification of fixed-qubit quantum programs at previously infeasible scales, while substantially improving expressiveness without compromising efficiency.

Büchi elevator automata naturally appear in several areas of formal methods as a structural expressibly-equivalent subclass of Büchi automata where every strongly connected component is either deterministic or inherently weak. It was shown that this class contains the majority of Büchi automata generated in practical applications, including LTL model-checking and verification of hyperproperties. Moreover, the elevator subclass enables more efficient complementation and determinization algorithms than unrestricted Büchi automata. In this paper, we introduce Emerson-Lei elevator automata, which is a generalization of Büchi elevator automata to richer acceptance conditions. We provide a complementation algorithm with a significantly better asymptotic complexity than the best known algorithm for unrestricted Emerson-Lei automata. The practical efficiency of our algorithm is demonstrated by an experimental comparison with the popular state-of-the-art tool Spot. Our work is, to the best of our knowledge, the first step towards practical algorithms for complementing, determinizing, and testing universality and inclusion of Emerson-Lei automata with rich acceptance conditions.

We present the first fully automatic framework for verifying relational properties of parameterized quantum programs , i.e., a program that, given an input size, generates a corresponding quantum circuit. We focus on verifying input-output correctness as well as equivalence. At the core of our approach is a new automata model, synchronized weighted tree automata (SWTAs), which compactly and precisely captures the infinite families of quantum states produced by parameterized programs. We introduce a class of transducers to model quantum gate semantics and develop composition algorithms for constructing transducers of parameterized circuits. Verification is reduced to functional inclusion or equivalence checking between SWTAs, for which we provide decision procedures. Our implementation demonstrates both the expressiveness and practical efficiency of the framework by verifying a diverse set of representative parameterized quantum programs with verification times ranging from milliseconds to seconds.

Matching regexes (regular expressions) is a common problem in many areas of computer science, with requirements on high speed and robust performance. Regexes with backreferences allow one to express certain patterns (even beyond regular) concisely, however, since the matching is usually done by backtracking, the matching speed can degrade to a degree that constitutes a service failure or a security threat. To facilitate high-speed matching of such regexes, we propose register set automata (RSAs), an extension of register automata where registers can contain sets of symbols (from a potentially infinite alphabet) and the following operations are supported: adding input values to registers, merging or clearing registers, and testing whether a register contains a value. We show that a large class of register automata can be transformed into deterministic RSAs, which can serve as a basis for fast matching of a family of regexes with single-letter capture groups and backreferences. We also give a derivative-based algorithm for transforming a large class of regexes with backreferences to register automata and show that the time complexity of matching is linear and quadratic to the length of the input for finite and infinite alphabets respectively. Our prototype implementation of a regex matcher shows that our approach can significantly improve the robustness of state-of-the-art regex matchers on regexes with backreferences. We also study the theoretical properties of the model and show that the emptiness problem for RSAs is decidable and complete for the F ω class and that RSAs are incomparable in expressive power to other popular automata models over data words.

Abstract We give new constructions for complementing subclasses of Emerson-Lei automata using modifications of rank-based Büchi automata complementation. In particular, we propose a specialized rank-based construction for a Boolean combination of Inf acceptance conditions, which heavily relies on a novel way of a run DAG labelling enhancing the ranking functions with models of the acceptance condition. Moreover, we propose a technique for complementing generalized Rabin automata, which are structurally as concise as general Emerson-Lei automata (but can have a larger acceptance condition). The construction is modular in the sense that it extends a given complementation algorithm for a condition $$\varphi $$ φ in a way that the resulting procedure handles conditions of the form $$\text {Fin}\wedge \varphi $$ Fin ∧ φ . The proposed constructions give upper bounds that are exponentially better than the state of the art for some of the classes.

Quantum technologies are progressing at an extraordinary pace and are poised to transform numerous sectors both nationally and globally. Among them, quantum computing stands out for its potential to revolutionize areas such as cryptography, optimization, and the simulation of quantum systems, offering dramatic speed-ups for specific classes of problems. As quantum devices evolve and become increasingly pervasive, guaranteeing their correctness is of paramount importance. This necessitates the development of rigorous methods and tools to analyze and verify their behavior. However, the construction of such verification frameworks presents fundamental challenges. Quantum phenomena such as superposition and entanglement give rise to computational behaviors that differ profoundly from those of classical systems, leading to inherently probabilistic models and exponentially large state spaces, even for relatively small programs. Addressing these challenges requires building on the extensive expertise of the formal methods community in classical program verification, while incorporating recent advances and collaborative efforts in quantum systems. An interesting challenge for the verification community is to design and implement novel verification frameworks that transfer the key strengths of classical verification, such as expressive specification, precise error detection, automation, and scalability, to the quantum domain. We expect that the results of this research will play a crucial role in enabling the dependable deployment of quantum technologies across a wide range of future applications.

We provide a positive answer to a long-standing open question of the decidability of the not-contains string predicate. Not-contains is practically relevant, for instance in symbolic execution of string manipulating programs. Particularly, we show that the predicate ¬Contains(x … x_n, y … y_m), where x … x_n and y … y_m are sequences of string variables constrained by regular languages, is decidable. Decidability of a not-contains predicate combined with chain-free word equations and regular membership constraints follows.

Abstract We present a verifier of quantum programs called AutoQ 2.0. Quantum programs extend quantum circuits (the domain of AutoQ 1.0) by classical control flow constructs, which enable users to describe advanced quantum algorithms in a formal and precise manner. The extension is highly non-trivial, as we needed to tackle both theoretical challenges (such as the treatment of measurement, the normalization problem, and lifting techniques for verification of classical programs with loops to the quantum world), and engineering issues (such as extending the input format with a support for specifying loop invariants). We have successfully used AutoQ 2.0 to verify two types of advanced quantum programs that cannot be expressed using only quantum circuits: the repeat-until-success (RUS) algorithm and the weak-measurement-based version of Grover’s search algorithm. AutoQ 2.0 can efficiently verify all our benchmarks: all RUS algorithms were verified instantly and, for the weak-measurement-based version of Grover’s search, we were able to handle the case of 100 qubits in $$\sim $$ ∼ 20 minutes.

Abstract Z3-Noodler is a fork of the Z3 SMT solver replacing its string theory implementation with a portfolio of decision procedures and a selection mechanism for choosing among them based on the features of the input formula. In this paper, we give an overview of the used decision procedures, including a novel length-based procedure, and their integration into a robust solver with a good overall performance, as witnessed by Z3-Noodler winning the string division of SMT-COMP’24 by a large margin. We also extended the solver with a support for model generation, which is essential for the use of the solver in practice.

We present a new method for the verification of quantum circuits based on a novel symbolic representation of sets of quantum states using level-synchronized tree automata (LSTAs). LSTAs extend classical tree automata by labeling each transition with a set of choices , which are then used to synchronize subtrees of an accepted tree. Compared to the traditional tree automata, LSTAs have an incomparable expressive power while maintaining important properties, such as closure under union and intersection, and decidable language emptiness and inclusion. We have developed an efficient and fully automated symbolic verification algorithm for quantum circuits based on LSTAs. The complexity of supported gate operations is at most quadratic, dramatically improving the exponential worst-case complexity of an earlier tree automata-based approach. Furthermore, we show that LSTAs are a promising model for parameterized verification , i.e., verifying the correctness of families of circuits with the same structure for any number of qubits involved, which principally lies beyond the capabilities of previous automated approaches.We implemented this method as a C++ tool and compared it with three symbolic quantum circuit verifiers and two simulators on several benchmark examples. The results show that our approach can solve problems with sizes orders of magnitude larger than the state of the art.

We introduce a novel decision procedure for solving the class of position string constraints , which includes string disequalities, ¬prefixof, ¬sujfixof, str.at , and ¬str.at. These constraints are generated frequently in almost any application of string constraint solving. Our procedure avoids expensive encoding of the constraints to word equations and, instead, reduces the problem to checking conflicts on positions satisfying an integer constraint obtained from the Parikh image of a polynomial-sized finite automaton with a special structure. By the reduction to counting, solving position constraints becomes NP-complete and for some cases even falls into PT IME . This is much cheaper than the previously used techniques, which either used reductions generating word equations and length constraints (for which modern string solvers use exponential-space algorithms) or incomplete techniques. Our method is relevant especially for automata-based string solvers, which have recently achieved the best results in terms of practical efficiency, generality, and completeness guarantees. This work allows them to excel also on position constraints, which used to be their weakness. Besides the efficiency gains, we show that our framework may be extended to solve a large fragment of ¬contains (in NE XP T IME ), for which decidability has been long open, and gives a hope to solve the general problem. Our implementation of the technique within the Z3-N OODLER solver significantly improves its performance on position constraints.

Abstract We present a new angle on solving quantified linear integer arithmetic based on combining the automata-based approach, where numbers are understood as bitvectors, with ideas from (nowadays prevalent) algebraic approaches, which work directly with numbers. This combination is enabled by a fine-grained version of the duality between automata and arithmetic formulae. In particular, we employ a construction where states of automaton are obtained as derivatives of arithmetic formulae: then every state corresponds to a formula. Optimizations based on techniques and ideas transferred from the world of algebraic methods are used on thousands of automata states, which dramatically amplifies their effect. The merit of this combination of automata with algebraic methods is demonstrated by our prototype implementation being competitive to and even superior to state-of-the-art SMT solvers.

Quantum circuit simulation is the basic tool for reasoning over quantum programs. Despite the tremendous advance in the simulator technology in the recent years, the performance of simulators is still unsatisfactory on non-trivial circuits, which slows down the development of new quantum systems. In this work, we develop a loop summarizing simulator based on multi-terminal binary decision diagrams (MTBDDs) with efficiently customized quantum gate operations. The simulator is capable of automatic loop summarization using symbolic execution, which saves repetitive computation for circuits with iterative structures. Experimental results show the simulator outperforms state-of-the-art simulators on some standard circuits, such as Grover's algorithm, by several orders of magnitude.

We propose a method for efficient handling string constraints with string-integer conversions. It extends the recently introduced stabilization-based procedure for solving string (dis)equations with regular and length constraints. Our approach is to translate the conversions into a linear integer arithmetic formula, together with regular constraints and word equations. We have integrated it into the string solver Z3-Noodler, and our experiments show that it is competitive and on some established benchmarks even several orders of magnitude faster than the state of the art.

Abstract Z3-Noodleris a fork ofZ3that replaces its string theory solver with a custom solver implementing the recently introduced stabilization-based algorithm for solving word equations with regular constraints. An extensive experimental evaluation shows thatZ3-Noodleris a fully-fledged solver that can compete with state-of-the-art solvers, surpassing them by far on many benchmarks. Moreover, it is often complementary to other solvers, making it a suitable choice as a candidate to a solver portfolio.

Abstract Mata is a well-engineered automata library written in C++ that offers a unique combination of speed and simplicity. It is meant to serve in applications such as string constraint solving and reasoning about regular expressions, and as a reference implementation of automata algorithms. Besides basic algorithms for (non)deterministic automata, it implements a fast simulation reduction and antichain-based language inclusion checking. The simplicity allows a straightforward access to the low-level structures, making it relatively easy to extend and modify. Besides the C++ API, the library also implements a Python binding. The library comes with a large benchmark of automata problems collected from relevant applications such as string constraint solving, regular model checking, and reasoning about regular expressions. We show that Mata is on this benchmark significantly faster than all libraries from a wide range of automata libraries we collected. Its usefulness in string constraint solving is demonstrated by the string solver Z3-Noodler, which is based on Mata and outperforms the state of the art in string constraint solving on many standard benchmarks.

Abstract We present a specification language and a fully automated tool named AutoQ for verifying quantum circuits symbolically. The tool implements the automata-based algorithm from [14] and extends it with the capabilities for symbolic reasoning. The extension allows to specify relational properties, i.e., relationships between states before and after executing a circuit. We present a number of use cases where we used AutoQ to fully automatically verify crucial properties of several quantum circuits, which have, to the best of our knowledge, so far been proved only with human help.

Abstract Complementation of nondeterministic Büchi automata (BAs) is an important problem in automata theory with numerous applications in formal verification, such as termination analysis of programs, model checking, or in decision procedures of some logics. We build on ideas from a recent work on BA determinization by Li et al. and propose a new modular algorithm for BA complementation. Our algorithm allows to combine several BA complementation procedures together, with one procedure for a subset of the BA’s strongly connected components (SCCs). In this way, one can exploit the structure of particular SCCs (such as when they are inherently weak or deterministic) and use more efficient specialized algorithms, regardless of the structure of the whole BA. We give a general framework into which partial complementation procedures can be plugged in, and its instantiation with several algorithms. The framework can, in general, produce a complement with an Emerson-Lei acceptance condition, which can often be more compact. Using the algorithm, we were able to establish an exponentially better new upper bound of $$\mathcal {O}(4^n)$$ O ( 4 n ) for complementation of the recently introduced class of elevator automata. We implemented the algorithm in a prototype and performed a comprehensive set of experiments on a large set of benchmarks, showing that our framework complements well the state of the art and that it can serve as a basis for future efficient BA complementation and inclusion checking algorithms.

Case split is a core proof rule in current decision procedures for the theory of string constraints. Its use is the primary cause of the state space explosion in string constraint solving, since it is the only rule that creates branches in the proof tree . Moreover, explicit handling of the case split rule may cause recomputation of the same tasks in multiple branches of the proof tree. In this paper, we propose a symbolic algorithm that significantly reduces such a redundancy. In particular, we encode a string constraint as a regular language and proof rules as rational transducers. This allows us to perform similar steps in the proof tree only once, alleviating the state space explosion. We also extend the encoding to handle arbitrary Boolean combinations of string constraints, length constraints, and regular constraints. In our experimental results, we validate that our technique works in many practical cases where other state-of-the-art solvers fail to provide an answer; our Python prototype implementation solved over 50% of string constraints that could not be solved by the other tools.

We introduce a new paradigm for analysing and finding bugs in quantum circuits. In our approach, the problem is given by a ‍triple { P } C { Q } and the question is whether, given a set P of quantum states on the input of a circuit C , the set of quantum states on the output is equal to (or included in) a set Q . While this is not suitable to specify, e.g., functional correctness of a quantum circuit, it is sufficient to detect many bugs in quantum circuits. We propose a technique based on tree automata to compactly represent sets of quantum states and develop transformers to implement the semantics of quantum gates over this representation. Our technique computes with an algebraic representation of quantum states, avoiding the inaccuracy of working with floating-point numbers. We implemented the proposed approach in a prototype tool and evaluated its performance against various benchmarks from the literature. The evaluation shows that our approach is quite scalable, e.g., we managed to verify a large circuit with 40 qubits and 141,527 gates, or catch bugs injected into a circuit with 320 qubits and 1,758 gates, where all tools we compared with failed. In addition, our work establishes a connection between quantum program verification and automata, opening new possibilities to exploit the richness of automata theory and automata-based verification in the world of quantum computing.

We present a new algorithm for solving string constraints. The algorithm builds upon a recent method for solving word equations and regular constraints that interprets string variables as languages rather than strings and, consequently, mitigates the combinatorial explosion that plagues other approaches. We extend the approach to handle linear integer arithmetic length constraints by combination with a known principle of equation alignment and splitting, and by extension to other common types of string constraints, yielding a fully-fledged string solver. The ability of the framework to handle unrestricted disequalities even extends one of the largest decidable classes of string constraints, the chain-free fragment. We integrate our algorithm into a DPLL-based SMT solver. The performance of our implementation is competitive and even significantly better than state-of-the-art string solvers on several established benchmarks obtained from applications in verification of string programs.

Abstract We present the toolRankerfor complementing Büchi automata (BAs).Rankerbuilds on our previous optimizations of rank-based BA complementation and pushes them even further using numerous heuristics to produce even smaller automata. Moreover, it contains novel optimizations of specialized constructions for complementing (i) inherently weak automata and (ii) semi-deterministic automata, all delivered in a robust tool. The optimizations significantly improve the usability ofRanker, as shown in an extensive experimental evaluation with real-world benchmarks, whereRankerproduced in the majority of cases a strictly smaller complement than other state-of-the-art tools.

Abstract We propose several heuristics for mitigating one of the main causes of combinatorial explosion in rank-based complementation of Büchi automata (BAs): unnecessarily high bounds on the ranks of states. First, we identifyelevator automata, which is a large class of BAs (generalizing semi-deterministic BAs), occurring often in practice, where ranks of states are bounded according to the structure of strongly connected components. The bounds for elevator automata also carry over to general BAs that contain elevator automata as a sub-structure. Second, we introduce two techniques for refining bounds on the ranks of BA states using data-flow analysis of the automaton. We implement out techniques as an extension of the toolRankerfor BA complementation and show that they indeed greatly prune the generated state space, obtaining significantly better results and outperforming other state-of-the-art tools on a large set of benchmarks.

This paper provides several optimizations of the rank-based approach for complementing Büchi automata. We start with Schewe’s theoretically optimal construction and develop a set of techniques for pruning its state space that are key to obtaining small complement automata in practice. In particular, the reductions (except one) have the property that they preserve (at least some) so-called super-tight runs, which are runs whose ranking is as tight as possible. Our evaluation on a large benchmark shows that the optimizations indeed significantly help the rank-based approach and that, in a large number of cases, the obtained complement is the smallest from those produced by state-of-the-art tools for Büchi complementation.

We study light-weight techniques for preprocessing of WSkS formulae in an automata- based decision procedure as implemented, e.g., in Mona. The techniques we use are based on antiprenexing, i.e., pushing quantifiers deeper into a formula. Intuitively, this tries to alleviate the explosion in the size of the constructed automata by making it happen sooner on smaller automata (and have the automata minimization reduce the output). The formula transformations that we use to implement antiprenexing may, however, be applied in different ways and extent and, if used in an unsuitable way, may also cause an explosion in the size of the formula and the automata built while deciding it. Therefore, our approach uses informed rules that use an estimation of the cost of constructing automata for WSkS formulae. The estimation is based on a model learnt from runs of the decision algorithm on various formulae. An experimental evaluation of our technique shows that antiprenexing can significantly boost the performance of the base WSkS decision procedure, sometimes allowing one to decide formulae that could not be decided before.

We propose a solution to the problem of efficient matching regular expressions (regexes) with bounded repetition, such as (ab){1,100}, using deterministic automata. For this, we introduce novel counting-set automata (CsAs) , automata with registers that can hold sets of bounded integers and can be manipulated by a limited portfolio of constant-time operations. We present an algorithm that compiles a large sub-class of regexes to deterministic CsAs. This includes (1) a novel Antimirov-style translation of regexes with counting to counting automata (CAs) , nondeterministic automata with bounded counters, and (2) our main technical contribution, a determinization of CAs that outputs CsAs. The main advantage of this workflow is that the size of the produced CsAs does not depend on the repetition bounds used in the regex (while the size of the DFA is exponential to them). Our experimental results confirm that deterministic CsAs produced from practical regexes with repetition are indeed vastly smaller than the corresponding DFAs. More importantly, our prototype matcher based on CsA simulation handles practical regexes with repetition regardless of sizes of counter bounds. It easily copes with regexes with repetition where state-of-the-art matchers struggle.

Deep packet inspection via regular expression (RE) matching is a crucial task of network intrusion detection systems (IDSes), which secure Internet connection against attacks and suspicious network traffic. Monitoring high-speed computer networks (100 Gbps and faster) in a single-box solution demands that the RE matching, traditionally based on finite automata (FAs), is accelerated in hardware. In this paper, we describe a novel FPGA architecture for RE matching that is able to process network traffic beyond 100 Gbps. The key idea is to reduce the required FPGA resources by leveraging approximate nondeterministic FAs (NFAs). The NFAs are compiled into a multi-stage architecture starting with the least precise stage with a high throughput and ending with the most precise stage with a low throughput. To obtain the reduced NFAs, we propose new approximate reduction techniques that take into account the profile of the network traffic. Our experiments showed that using our approach, we were able to perform matching of large sets of REs from SNORT, a popular IDS, on unprecedented network speeds.

SL-COMP aims at bringing together researchers interested on improving the state of the art of the automated deduction methods for Separation Logic (SL). The event took place twice until now and collected more than 1K problems for different fragments of SL. The input format of problems is based on the SMT-LIB format and therefore fully typed; only one new command is added to SMT-LIB’s list, the command for the declaration of the heap’s type. The SMT-LIB theory of SL comes with ten logics, some of them being combinations of SL with linear arithmetics. The competition’s divisions are defined by the logic fragment, the kind of decision problem (satisfiability or entailment) and the presence of quantifiers. Until now, SL-COMP has been run on the StarExec platform, where the benchmark set and the binaries of participant solvers are freely available. The benchmark set is also available with the competition’s documentation on a public repository in GitHub.

In 2014, Heizmann et al. proposed a novel framework for program termination analysis. The analysis starts with a termination proof of a sample path. The path is generalized to a Büchi automaton (BA) whose language (by construction) represents a set of terminating paths. All these paths can be safely removed from the program. The removal of paths is done using automata difference, implemented via BA complementation and intersection. The analysis constructs in this way a set of BAs that jointly "cover" the behavior of the program, thus proving its termination. An implementation of the approach in Ultimate Automizer won the 1st place in the Termination category of SV-COMP 2017.

We propose a novel automata model over the alphabet of rational numbers, which we call register automata over the rationals (RAℚ). It reads a sequence of rational numbers and outputs another rational number. RAℚis an extension of the well-known register automata (RA) over infinite alphabets, which are finite automata equipped with a finite number of registers/variables for storing values. Like in the standard RA, the RAℚmodel allows both equality and ordering tests between values. It, moreover, allows to perform linear arithmetic between certain variables. The model is quite expressive: in addition to the standard RA, it also generalizes other well-known models such as affine programs and arithmetic circuits. The main feature of RAℚis that despite the use of linear arithmetic, the so-called invariant problem-a generalization of the standard non-emptiness problem-is decidable. We also investigate other natural decision problems, namely, commutativity, equivalence, and reachability. For deterministic RAℚ, commutativity and equivalence are polynomial-time inter-reducible with the invariant problem.

We introduce a novel technique for verification and model synthesis of sequential programs. Our technique is based on learning an approximate regular model of the set of feasible paths in a program, and testing whether this model contains an incorrect behavior. Exact learning algorithms require checking equivalence between the model and the program, which is a difficult problem, in general undecidable. Our learning procedure is therefore based on the framework of probably approximately correct (PAC) learning, which uses sampling instead, and provides correctness guarantees expressed using the terms error probability and confidence. Besides the verification result, our procedure also outputs the model with the said correctness guarantees. Obtained preliminary experiments show encouraging results, in some cases even outperforming mature software verifiers.

As the speed of current computer networks increases, it is necessary to protect networks by security systems such as firewalls and intrusion detection systems operating at multigigabit speeds. Pattern matching is the time-critical operation of current IDS on multigigabit networks. Regular expressions are often used to describe malicious network patterns. This paper deals with fast regular expression matching using the deterministic finite automaton (DFA) with perfect hash function. We introduce decomposition of the problem on two parts: transformation of the input alphabet and usage of a fast DFA, and usage of perfect hashing to reduce space/speed tradeoff for DFA transition table.