We consider the design of bandwidth-demanding broadcasting applications using overlays in environments characterized by hosts with limited and asymmetric bandwidth, and significant heterogeneity in upload bandwidth. Such environments are critical to consider to extend the applicability of overlay multicast to mainstream Internet environments where insufficient bandwidth exists to support all hosts, but have not received adequate attention from the research community. We leverage the multitree framework and design heuristics to enable it to consider host contribution and operate in bandwidth-scarce environments. Our extensions seek to simultaneously achieve good utilization of system resources, performance to hosts commensurate to their contributions, and consistent performance. We have implemented the system and conducted an Internet evaluation on PlanetLab using real traces from previous operational deployments of an overlay broadcasting system. Our results indicate for these traces, our heuristics can improve the performance of high contributors by 10-240% and facilitate equitable bandwidth distribution among hosts with similar contributions.

Abstract — Hosts participating in overlay multicast applications have a wide range of heterogeneity in bandwidth and participation characteristics. In this paper, we highlight and show the need to systematically consider prioritization as a key criterion in the design of protocols for overlay multicast. We identify trade-offs in the design of prioritization heuristics in two important contexts. The first part of the paper considers prioritization strategies in the context of heterogeneity in node outgoing bandwidth and node stay time durations, and a lack of correlation between the two dimensions. The second part of the paper considers bandwidth allocation and prioritization policies with multi-tree data delivery in environments with heterogeneity in outgoing bandwidth and a certain degree of altruistic behavior. We conduct a systematic study of the trade-offs using both real trace data, and sensitivity studies using synthetic workloads. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to identify and study these trade-offs, and to demonstrate the potential benefits of the resulting prioritization heuristics. I.

We consider the design of bandwidth-demanding broadcasting applications using overlays in environments characterized by hosts with limited and asymmetric bandwidth, and significant heterogeneity in outgoing bandwidth. Such environments are critical to consider to extend the applicability of overlay multicast to mainstream Internet environments where insufficient bandwidth exists to support all hosts, but have not received adequate attention from the research community. We leverage the multi-tree framework and design heuristics to enable it to consider host contribution and operate in bandwidth-scarce environments. Our extensions seek to simultaneously achieve good utilization of system resources, performance to hosts commensurate to their contributions, and consistent performance. We have implemented the system and conducted an Internet evaluation on Planet-Lab using real traces from previous operational deployments of an overlay broadcasting system. Our results indicate for these traces, our heuristics can improve the performance of high contributors by 10-240% and facilitate equitable bandwidth distribution among hosts with similar contributions.